Lab-Grown vs Natural Diamond: Are They The Same?

Lab-Grown vs Natural Diamond: Are They The Same?

Whether it’s a casual onlooker or a seasoned jewelry enthusiast, people have always been fascinated by the allure and mystique of diamonds. These captivating gemstones have long symbolized love, wealth, and prestige.

However, in recent years, the diamond industry has been disrupted by the emergence of lab-grown diamonds, a more cost-effective and sustainable alternative to traditionally mined diamonds. This has sparked a debate among consumers, jewelers, and industry experts: Are lab-grown and natural diamonds indeed the same?

This article will explore the origins, characteristics, and critical differences between lab-grown and natural diamonds. We’ll also discuss the factors to consider when choosing between these two options and help you make an informed decision that aligns with your preferences and values.


Where Do Diamonds Come From?

Diamonds are the hardest substance on Earth, thanks to their unique atomic structure. This rigid three-dimensional structure creates a solid and durable crystalline lattice, making them resistant to scratching, abrasion, and deformation. They are formed deep within the planet’s mantle under immense heat and pressure.


Natural Diamonds

As mentioned, natural diamonds are formed through a process deep within the Earth’s mantle under immense heat and pressure. This process can take billions of years, making natural diamonds a true rarity and a testament to the power of nature.

The journey of a natural diamond is remarkable. Over billions of years, these captivating gems are brought closer to the surface through volcanic eruptions, where they are eventually mined and extracted.

This unique origin story, combined with the inherent scarcity of natural diamonds, contributes to their perceived value and desirability.


Lab-Grown Diamonds

In contrast to their natural counterparts, lab-grown diamonds are produced in a controlled laboratory environment. Using advanced technology, these diamonds are created through a process that mimics the natural diamond formation process but at a much faster rate. The two primary methods for lab-grown diamond production are:

  • High Pressure, High Temperature (HPHT): This method involves subjecting a small diamond “seed” to extreme heat and pressure, similar to the conditions found deep within the Earth’s mantle.
  • Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD): In this process, a diamond “seed” is placed in a vacuum chamber, exposed to a hydrocarbon gas, broken down, and deposited as a thin layer of diamond material.
 

The resulting lab-grown diamonds are chemically, physically, and optically identical to natural diamonds, with the key difference being their origin. While natural diamonds are millions of years old, lab-grown diamonds can be produced in weeks or months.


Distinguishing Diamonds Through Diamond Morphology/Features

While lab-grown and natural diamonds may appear visually identical, several key features can help distinguish them:

  • Color Zoning: Natural diamonds often exhibit subtle variations in color within the stone, known as color zoning. This is a result of the natural diamond formation process and the impurities present in the environment. Lab-grown diamonds, on the other hand, typically display a more uniform color distribution.
  • Dark Metallic Inclusions: Natural diamonds may contain dark metallic inclusions, remnants of the minerals present during the natural formation. These inclusions are rarely seen in lab-grown diamonds.
  • Weak Strain Patterns: Due to the different formation processes, natural diamonds often display weak strain patterns, which can be observed under a microscope. Lab-grown diamonds, on the other hand, typically exhibit more uniform strain patterns.
  • Distinctive Patterns and Colors of Ultraviolet Fluorescence: When exposed to ultraviolet light, natural and lab-grown diamonds can exhibit different patterns and colors of fluorescence, which can be a helpful distinguishing feature.
 

These morphological and feature-based differences can be detected by trained gemologists using specialized equipment to identify a diamond’s origin accurately.


Which Should You Choose Between Lab-Grown and Natural Diamond?

Your choice depends on your values, budget, and preferences. It’s crucial to weigh the various factors and make a decision that aligns with your individual needs and desires. Here are some of the factors one should consider when choosing what to purchase between lab-grown and natural diamonds:

Price

One of the primary advantages of lab-grown diamonds is their relatively lower price point compared to natural diamonds of similar size, cut, clarity, and color. This makes them more accessible to a broader range of consumers, particularly those on a tighter budget.

Value

While lab-grown diamonds may have a lower price tag, their long-term value and resale potential may be lower than natural diamonds. Natural diamonds are generally considered to hold their value better over time, especially for rare and high-quality specimens.

Sustainable and Ethical Sourcing

Lab-grown diamonds are often touted as a more sustainable and ethical option, as they do not require the same environmental impact and resource extraction as natural diamond mining. This can be an essential consideration for those seeking beautiful and responsible luxury, making them an appealing choice for these consumers.

Look

Both lab-grown and natural diamonds can be visually stunning, with the final appearance largely dependent on the stone’s cut, clarity, and color. Trained gemologists may be able to detect subtle differences, but for the average consumer, the visual appeal of the diamond is often the primary concern.


Shop a Wide Variety of Diamonds at Rogers Jewelry

The debate between lab-grown and natural diamonds is ongoing, with valid arguments. But regardless of origin, all authentic diamonds are alluring and beautiful, so the choice ultimately rests with the individual, based on their preferences, budget, and values.

At Rogers Jewelry, we’re committed to helping our clients make an informed decision when purchasing their prized diamonds. Our expert team, led by our resident GIA graduate gemologist Jeff Bertman, will readily guide you during the purchase, ensuring you receive the correct information to leave you confident and satisfied.

Visit our physical shop at 1250 Hancock Street, Quincy Center, or check out our online shop to browse our collection and experience one of the best diamond-buying journeys near you.

Share:

More Posts

Understanding the GIA Diamond Grading Scales

Diamonds are beautiful gemstones renowned for their perceived rarity and desirability. Their brilliance, rarity, and enduring value symbolize love, luxury, and prestige. However, some unscrupulous

column header

Something Different

By: Jeffrey M. Bertman Graduate Gemologist For those who already own a fine complement of white diamonds and want something unique, there are yellow diamonds.